After the Capital Asset Value Model (CAPM) was created in the 1960s and 1970s, financial researchers began to test how well this theoretical model actually worked in the real world.
Between broad computing power and greater data access, the 1980s became an important era for verifying the validity of CAPM as analysts explored the effectiveness of beta in anticipating future revenue.
Surprisingly, the general sensitivity that emerged is that the ability to predict better returns is quite weak.
In the 60 years or more since the advent of CAPM, how much has model and beta expected returns improved over the decades? To find out, we analyzed each firm trading on the NYSE and NASDAQ and built a portfolio of companies based on their systematic risk (beta) using monthly returns and 12-month rolling calculations.
If a firm had a beta below 0.5, it was allocated to a lower beta portfolio. Firms with more than 1.5 betas were assigned to its top beta competitors.
Using these groups, we examined how portfolios worked in subsequent years-both on a medium and market-cap-based basis. Portfolios were restructured according to new beta counts each year.
|High-beta portfolio median returns||Low-beta portfolio median returns||High-beta portfolio market-weighted returns||Low-beta portfolio market-weighted returns||Percentage of the year in line with CAPM|
As it turns out, the 1990s were a terrible time for Beta. On an annualized basis, a low beta portfolio performs an average of 6 percentage points better than its higher beta counterparts over a decade, generating 18.14% vs. 12.12% return.
We then examined the percentage of years that reflected the CAPM forecast on a general basis over decades. In only four of the 10 years has CAPM accurately predicted returns. That is, positive market return years should be consistent with high beta betting low beta portfolios and negative market return years should be consistent with low beta betting high beta portfolios. This means that CAPM has done worse than a random walk during this period and helps explain why researchers of the era were so skeptical about the model.
But the 1980s were something external. As the decade progresses, beta and CAPM become a better predictor. From 2010 to 2020, CAPM was right in 10 of the 11 years.
In fact, every decade since the 1980s, a higher beta portfolio generates slightly more of a 5 percent point premium annually than its lower beta peers. That is, the high beta portfolio returns an average of 15.53% compared to the low-beta 10.34% return.
That said, the results highlight that beta is not as bad as often predicted for future returns. The 1990s were a terrible time for beta and CAPM, but since that decade, beta has been a good predictor of future returns.
If you liked this post, be sure to subscribe Entrepreneurial investors.
All posts are the author’s opinion. As such, they should not be construed as investment advice, or the opinions expressed must not reflect the views of the CFA Institute or the author’s employer.
Photo Credit: © Getty Images / SK Lim / IEM
Professional education for CFA Institute members
Members of the CFA Institute have the ability to earn self-assessment and self-reporting professional education (PL) credit, including content Entrepreneurial investors. Members can easily record credit using their online PL tracker.